Is Your Employer Keeping Poor Performing Investments in Your 401(k) Plan?
Key Takeaways
- Employers and other plan fiduciaries must prudently select and monitor 401(k) investments, including evaluating performance, expenses, and available alternatives.
- Consistently underperforming investments can cost employees substantial retirement savings, especially when problems go unaddressed for years.
- Ordinary market losses aren't necessarily ERISA violations, but failing to prudently monitor or replace unsuitable investments may constitute a fiduciary breach.
- If mismanaged investments have hurt your retirement savings, contact Morgan & Morgan for a free case evaluation to learn about your rights.
Injured?
Nobody expects every investment in their 401(k) to be a winner. Markets rise and fall, and even well-managed investments can experience difficult periods.
But what happens when an investment consistently underperforms, charges high fees, and remains in your employer's retirement plan year after year?
At some point, employees may have reason to question whether those responsible for their retirement plan are doing their jobs.
Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), fiduciaries responsible for selecting and monitoring 401(k) investment options must act prudently and in the interests of plan participants.
When they fail to properly oversee those investments, employees may suffer preventable financial losses.
Why Employers Must Monitor 401(k) Investments
When your employer offers a 401(k), someone must decide which investment options will be available to participants. These choices commonly include mutual funds, target-date retirement funds, and other investment products. Plan fiduciaries must evaluate those options before including them in the plan and continue monitoring them afterward.
That responsibility doesn't disappear once an investment makes it onto the menu.
A fund that was appropriate five years ago might no longer be a prudent choice because of persistent performance problems, management changes, unreasonable expenses, or other concerns.
Fiduciaries must respond appropriately when their monitoring identifies issues.
How Poor Investments Can Damage Your Retirement
Your 401(k) depends on contributions and investment growth to build wealth over time.
When an investment consistently trails appropriate benchmarks or comparable alternatives, that performance gap may have lasting consequences.
Consider two hypothetical investments. One earns an average annual return of 7%, while another earns 5%. If each starts with $100,000 and receives no additional contributions, after 20 years the first would grow to approximately $387,000, while the second would grow to approximately $265,000. That's a difference of more than $120,000.
Ordinary Investment Losses vs. Fiduciary Mismanagement
An investment losing money does not automatically mean your employer violated ERISA.
Market downturns happen. Investments can perform poorly despite reasonable oversight, and fiduciaries are not required to predict future market performance.
The legal question generally focuses on whether fiduciaries followed a prudent decision-making process based on the circumstances at the time.
Potential concerns include ignoring persistent underperformance without adequate justification, failing to examine fund expenses, overlooking changes in investment management, or retaining investments despite evidence that they are no longer suitable.
An investment's performance must also be evaluated against an appropriate benchmark, accounting for its objectives and risks.
Warning Signs of Inadequate Investment Oversight
Employees may want to examine their plan more closely when investments repeatedly lag comparable funds, have unusually high expenses, or remain available despite longstanding concerns.
Other warning signs may include a limited selection of appropriate investment alternatives or significant changes to a fund's management that appear to go unaddressed.
Participants can review investment disclosures, fund fact sheets, historical performance, and expense ratios.
These materials may reveal questions worth investigating, although establishing a fiduciary breach generally requires examining information beyond what participants receive.
Can Poor 401(k) Investment Selection Lead to an ERISA Lawsuit?
If fiduciaries failed to prudently select or monitor investments, affected participants may be able to pursue legal action under ERISA. Claims may involve imprudent investment selections, failure to replace unsuitable options, or excessive investment-related expenses.
When challenged decisions affected numerous participants, a class action may be appropriate.
Potential remedies depend on the allegations and evidence, but may include restoring losses to the retirement plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue my employer for poor performing 401(k) investments?
Possibly. Poor performance alone is generally insufficient. However, if fiduciaries failed to prudently select or monitor investments and that failure caused losses, an ERISA claim may be available.
How long can an employer keep underperforming investments in a retirement plan?
ERISA establishes no fixed deadline for removing underperforming investments. Fiduciaries must monitor investments appropriately and respond prudently to relevant information.
Does ERISA require employers to monitor 401(k) investment performance?
Yes. Fiduciaries responsible for investment oversight have an ongoing obligation to monitor the suitability of plan investments, including relevant performance, risks, and costs.
What qualifies as a breach of fiduciary duty involving 401(k) investments?
A breach may involve imprudent selection or monitoring practices, unreasonable expenses, or decisions influenced by improper interests. Whether a breach occurred depends on the circumstances and resulting harm.
Can employees collectively sue over mismanaged retirement investments?
Yes. Participants affected by common investment decisions may potentially pursue an ERISA class action, subject to applicable legal and procedural requirements.
Your Retirement Deserves Responsible Oversight
You shouldn't have to wonder whether the people overseeing your retirement investments are paying attention.
If you believe your employer has allowed unsuitable investments to remain in your 401(k) plan, contact Morgan & Morgan for a free case evaluation. Our attorneys can review the circumstances and help determine whether you may have grounds to pursue an ERISA claim.

We've got your back
Injured?
Not sure what to do next?
We'll guide you through everything you need to know.
