Are Employers Using 401(k) Plan Assets to Reduce Their Own Expenses?
Key Takeaways
- When employees leave before becoming fully vested, forfeited employer contributions remain within the retirement plan and must be used for permitted purposes.
- Employers may legally use 401(k) forfeitures to offset contributions, but certain practices that improperly benefit the company may raise fiduciary concerns.
- Employees may have grounds for an ERISA claim if improper forfeiture decisions violate fiduciary duties and cause financial harm.
- If you suspect your employer is misusing retirement plan assets, contact Morgan & Morgan for a free case evaluation to explore your options.
Injured?
Your employer promises to contribute money toward your retirement. You contribute your share, the company contributes its share, and the plan is supposed to help you build financial security.
But what happens when employees leave before becoming fully vested in their employer's contributions?
In many 401(k) plans, those unvested contributions are forfeited. The money remains within the retirement plan and can be used for certain purposes permitted by the plan's terms and federal law.
Here's where things get complicated: employers may use those forfeitures to reduce future company contributions, potentially saving themselves substantial amounts of money.
That practice can be legal. But questions may arise when employers use forfeitures in ways that conflict with their fiduciary obligations, particularly if participants are left paying expenses that might otherwise have been covered.
What Happens to Unvested 401(k) Contributions?
Many employers offer matching or other retirement contributions subject to a vesting schedule.
Vesting determines when employees obtain a nonforfeitable right to those employer contributions.
For example, an employee might leave a company before becoming fully vested and forfeit a portion of the employer-funded account balance.
Employees generally retain their own salary-deferral contributions, while unvested employer contributions may be forfeited under the plan's rules.
Those forfeitures do not simply become unrestricted corporate money. They remain subject to the retirement plan's governing requirements.
How Employers Can Use Forfeited Retirement Funds
Depending on the plan's terms and applicable rules, forfeitures may be used to reduce future employer contributions, pay permissible plan administrative expenses, or provide additional benefits to participants.
Using forfeitures to offset employer contributions is not inherently unlawful. However, disputes have arisen over whether fiduciaries improperly prioritize the employer's financial interests when deciding how to use forfeited funds.
Consider an employer that routinely uses forfeitures to reduce its own contribution expenses while charging participants for plan administration.
Employees may question whether that arrangement reflects prudent fiduciary decision-making, especially when the plan permits alternative uses of forfeitures.
Whether the conduct violates ERISA depends on the plan documents, the nature of the decision, fiduciary authority, and applicable law.
When Employees May Be Paying Expenses Unnecessarily
Retirement plans routinely incur expenses for recordkeeping, administration, legal services, and investment management. Some of these expenses may legitimately be charged to participants.
The concern is whether fiduciaries have used their authority improperly, causing employees to bear costs that should have been handled differently under the plan or ERISA.
For example, if an employer's decisions are motivated by protecting company finances at participants' expense, those decisions may deserve closer examination.
Still, an employer's financial benefit does not, by itself, establish an ERISA violation. Employer contribution decisions can involve nonfiduciary business functions, and plan terms may authorize specific forfeiture uses.
ERISA's Rules for Protecting Retirement Assets
ERISA generally requires retirement plan fiduciaries to act prudently and loyally when managing plan assets. They must follow valid plan documents, avoid prohibited transactions, and make fiduciary decisions for the benefit of participants and beneficiaries.
Plan forfeitures can create challenging questions because employers may benefit financially from how those funds are allocated.
A legal investigation may examine how the plan describes forfeiture use, who controls the allocations, whether participants incurred losses, and whether the relevant decisions involved fiduciary conduct.
Can Forfeiture Practices Lead to a Class Action?
Employees have brought ERISA lawsuits challenging the way employers use 401(k) forfeitures.
These claims may allege breaches of fiduciary duties, improper expense allocations, or other violations.
The legal theories are contested, and not every forfeiture arrangement supports a lawsuit.
When the same allegedly improper practice affects participants across a retirement plan, class action litigation may provide a way to address common claims.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can employers use forfeited 401(k) funds to reduce their own contributions?
Federal retirement plan rules generally permit forfeitures to reduce employer contributions when authorized by the plan and applicable law. Whether a particular arrangement creates fiduciary concerns requires further analysis.
What happens to unvested 401(k) contributions when employees leave a company?
Unvested employer contributions may be forfeited according to the plan's vesting and distribution rules. The funds generally remain within the retirement plan for permissible uses.
Can employers use retirement plan assets to pay business expenses?
Generally, retirement assets cannot be diverted to ordinary corporate expenses. However, permissible plan administrative expenses may be paid from plan assets under applicable rules.
When does the use of 401(k) forfeitures violate ERISA?
Potential violations depend on factors such as plan provisions, prohibited transactions, misuse of assets, fiduciary misconduct, and whether participants suffered legally recognizable harm.
Can employees bring a class action lawsuit over improper 401(k) forfeiture practices?
Potentially. Where common forfeiture practices allegedly violate ERISA and affect numerous participants, a class action may be possible.
Your Retirement Plan Shouldn't Be Managed at Your Expense
The way your employer handles forfeited contributions can have real consequences for the people participating in its retirement plan.
If you suspect your employer has improperly used retirement funds or shifted unnecessary costs onto employees, contact Morgan & Morgan for a free case evaluation. We can help assess whether the circumstances may warrant legal action.

We've got your back
Injured?
Not sure what to do next?
We'll guide you through everything you need to know.
