Did Your Employer Fail to Tell You How to Avoid a Tobacco Surcharge on Your Health Plan?

5 min read time
Headshot of Marc Edelman, a Tampa-based unpaid wages and overtime lawyer at Morgan & Morgan Reviewed by Marc Edelman, Attorney at Morgan & Morgan, on November 19, 2026.

Key Takeaways

  • Federal rules generally require qualifying tobacco wellness programs to disclose reasonable alternatives that may allow employees to avoid surcharges.
  • Missing, incomplete, or misleading notices may cause employees to pay additional health insurance premiums they could otherwise have avoided.
  • Employers and health plans that fail to provide required disclosures may face legal challenges, including potential ERISA class action lawsuits.
  • If you weren't told how to avoid a tobacco surcharge, contact Morgan & Morgan for a free case evaluation to learn whether you may have a claim.

Injured? 

We can help.

You're enrolling in health insurance through your employer when you notice an additional premium for employees who use tobacco.

You answer the required questions, complete your enrollment, and accept the higher cost.

But what if there was a way to avoid the charge, and nobody properly explained it to you?

Under federal law, qualifying tobacco-related wellness programs generally must inform participants about the availability of reasonable alternative standards.

When employers or plan administrators fail to provide required information, employees may end up paying surcharges they could have avoided.

Those failures may raise legal questions under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and other federal health plan requirements.

What Employers Must Tell Employees About Tobacco Surcharges

Many employer-sponsored group health plans use tobacco-related wellness programs to encourage healthier behavior.

These programs may charge higher premiums to tobacco users while allowing employees to avoid the additional expense by satisfying a reasonable alternative. However, federal regulations require certain notices explaining the availability of those alternatives.

For health-contingent wellness programs, plan materials describing the program's terms generally must disclose the availability of a reasonable alternative standard and, where applicable, the possibility of a waiver.

For outcome-based programs, additional disclosure requirements may apply when employees are notified that they have not satisfied the initial standard.

These requirements are designed to ensure employees understand their opportunities to qualify for the lower premium.

How Reasonable Alternatives Are Supposed to Work

Consider a health plan that charges employees an additional $100 per month if they use tobacco. The plan also offers a smoking cessation program that allows participating employees to avoid that surcharge.

Under a compliant arrangement, an employee may be able to qualify for the lower premium by participating in the cessation program, even if they do not successfully quit tobacco. The employer or plan administrator must provide required information about the alternative and ensure it meets applicable standards.

Employees should not be forced to navigate unreasonable obstacles simply to access a benefit they're legally entitled to pursue.

The regulations also address when alternatives must be made available and how participants may qualify for the reward during a plan year.

Common Tobacco Surcharge Notice Problems

Problems can arise when employers provide incomplete enrollment materials or fail to explain available options. For example, a notice might tell employees that tobacco users pay more without explaining that a reasonable alternative exists.

Other disclosures might mention a wellness program but omit essential information about how employees can obtain further details or qualify for the alternative.

In certain circumstances, misleading communications may cause employees to believe they must quit tobacco entirely to avoid the surcharge.

A statement that employees can avoid the charge only by becoming tobacco-free may be problematic when federal rules require a qualifying alternative.

These details matter because employees typically rely on employer-provided materials when making healthcare enrollment decisions.

How Missing Notices Can Cost Employees Money

An employee who pays an additional $100 each month because of a tobacco surcharge could spend $1,200 over a year.

If that employee could have qualified for a compliant alternative but was never properly informed, those charges may warrant investigation.

Across a large workforce, similarly inadequate notices could result in substantial additional premium payments.

Employees should review their enrollment guides, wellness program descriptions, tobacco-use questionnaires, and payroll records.

These documents may help establish what information was provided, how the surcharge operated, and whether employees received the disclosures required by federal law.

Can Missing Notices Lead to an ERISA Class Action?

Employees have challenged tobacco surcharge programs on the grounds that employers or plan administrators failed to provide required reasonable-alternative notices.

A claim may examine whether notices were legally sufficient, whether the program itself complied with federal requirements, and what relief affected participants may pursue. When the same deficient disclosures were used for numerous employees, common issues may support class action litigation.

The outcome depends on the specific plan, available evidence, and applicable law.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does my employer have to tell me how to avoid a tobacco surcharge?

Qualifying health-contingent tobacco wellness programs generally must provide required notices concerning reasonable alternative standards, including disclosures in materials describing the program.

Can a tobacco surcharge violate federal law even if employees are offered a wellness program?

Yes. Merely offering a wellness program does not establish compliance. The program must satisfy applicable requirements involving alternatives, notices, and other conditions.

What notices must employers provide about tobacco surcharge alternatives?

Required disclosures generally explain the availability of reasonable alternatives or waivers and may need to include contact information and other prescribed details, depending on the program.

Can employees challenge surcharges paid because of missing or misleading notices?

Employees may have legal claims if required notices were deficient and the relevant circumstances support relief under applicable law.

Can an employer face a class action lawsuit for improper tobacco surcharge disclosures?

Yes. Common notice failures affecting numerous employees may support class action claims when the legal requirements are satisfied.

Don't Pay the Price for Missing Information

Your employer's health plan should provide the information federal law requires, especially when that information can affect your paycheck.

If you've paid a tobacco surcharge without being properly informed about available alternatives, contact Morgan & Morgan for a free case evaluation. Our attorneys can help determine whether your employer's wellness program may have violated federal law and whether you can seek relief.

Disclaimer
This website is meant for general information and not legal advice.

Injured?

Not sure what to do next?
We'll guide you through everything you need to know.