Are Employers Offering Overpriced Voluntary Benefits That Cost Employees More Than Necessary?
Key Takeaways
- Voluntary benefits like supplemental life, accident, and critical illness insurance may cost employees more than necessary when premiums are unreasonably high.
- Some voluntary benefit programs fall under ERISA, requiring those acting as fiduciaries to prudently oversee covered benefit arrangements.
- Excessive premiums, inadequate oversight, and conflicted provider selections may support legal claims when applicable fiduciary duties are violated.
- If you're overpaying for workplace voluntary benefits, contact Morgan & Morgan for a free case evaluation to explore your legal options.
Injured?
When your employer offers additional benefits, it's easy to assume those options have been carefully selected with employees' interests in mind. After all, workplace benefits are supposed to provide financial protection, peace of mind, and access to coverage you might otherwise struggle to obtain.
But what if your employer's voluntary benefits are significantly more expensive than comparable options available elsewhere? And what if the companies selling those benefits are collecting substantial profits while employees shoulder the cost?
Depending on how the benefits program is structured and managed, overpriced voluntary insurance may raise questions under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).
What Are Voluntary Employee Benefits?
Voluntary benefits are additional products or services offered through an employer, typically with employees choosing whether to participate and often paying the premiums themselves. Common examples include supplemental life insurance, accident insurance, critical illness coverage, hospital indemnity insurance, and disability-related products.
These plans can provide valuable financial protection. For example, hospital indemnity coverage may provide specified cash benefits following a covered hospitalization, while accident insurance may help offset certain expenses associated with an injury.
Employers frequently negotiate with insurance carriers and brokers to make these options available through payroll deductions. However, employees may have little insight into how providers were selected, how premiums were determined, or whether lower-cost alternatives were considered.
How Overpriced Benefits Can Hurt Employees
Imagine purchasing supplemental insurance through your workplace because you believe you're receiving access to competitive group pricing. You pay the premiums month after month, potentially for years. Later, you discover that comparable coverage might have been available at substantially lower rates.
The difference could add up to hundreds or thousands of dollars over time, depending on the coverage and premium.
Price comparisons must account for policy terms, eligibility, coverage limits, exclusions, and other factors. A more expensive product is not necessarily unreasonable simply because another insurer offers a cheaper policy.
Nevertheless, employees may have legitimate concerns when high premiums result from inadequate oversight or arrangements that improperly benefit providers.
Does ERISA Protect Employees Who Purchase Voluntary Benefits?
Some employer-sponsored voluntary benefit programs are subject to ERISA. Others qualify for an exclusion from ERISA coverage.
Generally, a voluntary insurance arrangement may fall outside ERISA when the employer makes no contributions, participation is completely voluntary, the employer performs only limited administrative functions without endorsing the program, and the employer receives no improper consideration.
When a voluntary benefits arrangement constitutes an ERISA-covered plan, fiduciary responsibilities may apply to those exercising relevant authority or control. That can include obligations involving prudent administration, loyalty to participants, and proper management of plan assets.
Determining whether ERISA applies is an important first step in evaluating a potential claim.
What Responsibilities Do Employers Have?
For ERISA-covered voluntary benefit programs, individuals acting as fiduciaries must comply with applicable fiduciary obligations.
Those duties may include prudently selecting and monitoring service providers, evaluating expenses where appropriate, and avoiding improper conflicts of interest.
Employers and brokers are not automatically fiduciaries for every decision involving an insurance product. Their responsibilities depend on the arrangement and the functions they perform.
Questions may arise when a benefits provider remains in place despite significant pricing concerns, when high commissions influence plan decisions, or when fiduciaries fail to address conflicts that harm participants.
When Overpriced Benefits May Lead to an ERISA Lawsuit
Recent ERISA litigation has challenged allegedly excessive voluntary benefit premiums, broker compensation, and failures to monitor insurance arrangements.
These lawsuits involve developing legal theories, and allegations of high prices do not guarantee that a court will find a fiduciary violation.
Potential claims may require evidence that the program is covered by ERISA, that the defendants performed fiduciary functions, and that misconduct caused compensable harm.
Where numerous employees participate in the same allegedly improper arrangement, class action litigation may be considered.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can employers be sued for offering overpriced voluntary benefits?
Potentially. If an ERISA-covered plan is involved and responsible fiduciaries breached their duties, employees may have legal claims. High premiums alone do not automatically establish liability.
Are voluntary employee benefit plans covered by ERISA?
Some are, while others qualify for an exemption from ERISA coverage. The answer depends on the employer's involvement, contributions, endorsement, and other factors.
Do employers have a fiduciary duty to compare voluntary benefit costs?
Where ERISA fiduciary duties apply, responsible fiduciaries may need to evaluate provider arrangements and relevant costs prudently. There is no universal requirement to select the lowest-priced policy.
What happens when employers select expensive benefits despite better available options?
The circumstances may warrant investigation, particularly if the decision involved conflicts of interest or imprudent fiduciary conduct that caused financial harm.
Can employees file a class action lawsuit over overpriced voluntary insurance?
Employees with common claims arising from an ERISA-covered arrangement may be able to pursue class action litigation.
You Deserve Fair Treatment From Your Workplace Benefits
Employees shouldn't have to wonder whether their workplace insurance premiums are being driven up by arrangements that favor providers over participants.
If you believe you're paying excessive premiums for voluntary benefits through your employer, contact Morgan & Morgan for a free case evaluation. We can help assess whether the arrangement may give rise to legal claims and what options may be available to recover losses.

We've got your back
Injured?
Not sure what to do next?
We'll guide you through everything you need to know.
