Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

NEW YORK RENTAL CAR ACCIDENT ATTORNEY

Rental car accidents in New York City create tangled liability disputes between the renter, the rental agency, and other drivers. Morgan & Morgan sorts through overlapping policies, determines which carrier is liable, and pursues recovery.

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

    When a Rental Car Accident Puts Your Plans on Pause

    Rental car accidents in New York can leave drivers and passengers facing injuries, property damage, and complicated insurance claims. Whether it’s a minor fender-bender or a serious crash, navigating liability and coverage can be confusing and stressful.

    New York law allows accident victims to pursue compensation when another driver’s negligence causes harm. These cases often involve rental companies, insurance policies, and multiple parties, making experienced legal advocacy essential to recover medical expenses, lost wages, and other damages.

    If you were injured in a rental car accident in New York, a Morgan & Morgan attorney can help protect your rights and guide you through the claims process. Schedule a free, no-obligation case evaluation through our website. Let us fight for the compensation you need to recover.

    150,000+ Five Star Reviews

    The reasons why clients trust Morgan & Morgan.

    Quotation icon
    The Morgan & Morgan Team were Great! They helped me with my claim and even helped me get the treatment I needed, and everything was done in a fashionable time. After my accident, it was hard for me to commute around, so using their online portal helped lighten a load. I’m glad I chose Morgan & Morgan.
    Adifah W.
    New York, NY
    Star Star Star Star Star
    Quotation icon
    So far, I've found the services provided to me by the firm of Morgan & Morgan to be very professional and knowledgeable.They would get 10 stars from me, if it was possible, to rate their efficiency and the speed that they respond to my concerns!
    Mary M.
    New York, NY
    Star Star Star Star Star
    Video thumbnail for 43c4ys7m72
    Play video
    Quotation icon
    Response time has been wonderful, helpful, caring and hard working.
    Mark D.
    New York, NY
    Star Star Star Star Star
    Quotation icon
    Morgan and Morgan has been great from the start. They have clear , precise communication , and are super friendly and knowledgeable. Also , You don’t pay them a dime unless they win your case ! What a great value. Thanks , Morgan & Morgan ! 11/10
    christopher
    New York, NY
    Star Star Star Star Star
    Video thumbnail for 0ycee6119j
    Play video
    Quotation icon
    Alana and Amanda are the absolute best duo in the world! I am so blessed to have them on my side! They are so skilled, knowledgeable and trustworthy! They continue to keep me and my family informed and up to date throughout the process. There aren’t enough words in the English dictionary to explain my extreme gratitude for both of them. Thank you so much for everything Alana & Amanda!!
    Jeaneé T.
    New York, NY
    Star Star Star Star Star
    Quotation icon
    I am working with them for my son's case they are always there to answer any questions I have and have supported me and my case since day one Nicholas brown is amazing
    Erika M.
    New York, NY
    Star Star Star Star Star
    Video thumbnail for w975ml0o2g
    Play video

    Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Based on select nationwide reviews.

    FAQ
    • What You Need to Know About Rental Car Insurance Companies in New York

      As mentioned earlier, auto insurance companies in New York usually provide different policies under different names and abbreviations. In addition, these companies may try to convince you to purchase certain policies even if you don't need them.

      Half of the time, some of these policies are usually provided by your existing personal auto insurance. Additionally, some credit card companies also provide insurance for eligible drivers.

      For this reason, it's always advisable to contact your credit card company beforehand if you intend to use your credit card to rent a car in New York.

      Similarly, talk to your personal auto insurance provider to determine if your current policy covers rental cars as well. This information can help you save money in the event of an accident and also establish the party responsible for the damages. 

    • Why You Need a Rental Car Accident Attorney in New York

      As discussed earlier, car rental companies in New York have different insurance policies. In addition, these policies usually come in abbreviations such as SLP, PAI, PEC, and so forth. Therefore, when you get into a car accident, you may not know what you are eligible for as compensation, especially if you don't understand the terms of the insurance policy. 

      An experienced car accident attorney can help break down these policies and determine the kind of compensation you are entitled to. This is one step you should never ignore because once the settlement agreement is reached and all the required legal documents signed, you may not be able to sue the insurance provider over the same claim. 

      Secondly, rental car insurance claims are more complicated than those involving non-rental cars. When it comes to rental cars, you might be eligible for compensation from multiple insurance companies. An experienced car accident attorney can review your case and advise you on the party responsible for the damages, ensuring you don't miss anything you're entitled to. 

      For instance, some drivers use their credit cards to rent cars in New York. The same drivers might also have their personal auto insurance. Things become even more complicated if they purchase car insurance offered by the rental company. In the event of an accident, it might be difficult to know which insurance company should pay for your damages. 

      And you shouldn't expect any insurance company to approach you, claiming responsibility for your compensation. Remember, insurance companies make their money from limiting the amount they spend on their clients or third-parties as compensation. So if you expect any insurance company to be honest with you about the settlement you're entitled to, then you'll be disappointed.

      In fact, these companies will most likely bring in their claims adjusters to evaluate the accident and find any reason possible to reduce the amount you're entitled to as compensation. To counter this tactic, you need an aggressive attorney who will fight for your rights, leaving no stone unturned. 

      Thirdly, New York is a no-fault state, making filing rental car accident claims even more complicated. 

    • What Is a No-Fault State?

      In a no-fault state, insured individuals are required to seek compensation for damages from their own insurance companies regardless of who was at fault for the accident. This means that if you get into a rental car accident with another driver, your own insurance company should compensate you for the damages even if you caused the accident. 

      The benefits may include medical bills, lost wages, housekeeping or transportation costs, prescription drugs, lost wages, and other qualifying factors. But one thing most people don't know is that in the event of an accident in New York, the claimant has only 30 days to submit a claim for these benefits. So failure to observe this rule could mean losing the benefits you need to support your lifestyle after the accident.  

      And that's not all — it's possible to file a claim against the other party even if the accident occurred in New York, a no-fault state. However, you must meet the no-fault threshold set for such accidents for this to happen.

      For instance, you must have suffered a serious injury to sue the other party for the accident in a no-fault state like New York. However, the state's laws interpret the term ''serious injuries'' differently, and whatever your definition is for such injuries might not be acceptable by the state's legal system. 

      The bottom line is hiring an attorney after a rental car accident helps you avoid the legal tussles involved in filing a claim for your injuries. From establishing the party responsible for the damages to interpreting the law on your behalf to ensure you receive the right compensation, a New York rental car accident lawyer can be of great help. 

    • How Morgan & Morgan Can Help

      Morgan & Morgan is the leading personal injury law firm in the United States, serving clients from all corners, New York included. Our law firm has provided legal representation services for personal injury victims for more than 35 years, having recovered over $30 billion worth of compensation.

      As the largest injury law firm in the country, we always have an army of attorneys ready to represent you after a car accident. We understand how complicated it can be to file a claim about a rental car accident in New York, but that's not something you need to worry about when working with one of our experienced attorneys. 

      The fact that you have Morgan & Morgan by your side significantly increases your chances of winning the claim. This is because insurance companies know that we don't play games when fighting for our client's rights. We also know that insurance companies like to take advantage of clients who are unaware of their rights and will come up with different tactics to avoid taking financial responsibility for the accident. 
       
      And given that New York is a no-fault state and there's a rental car involved, the entire process of filing a claim becomes way too complicated without an attorney. At Morgan & Morgan, we have helped our clients recover over $120 million in total as compensation for car accidents alone. So when insurance companies come up against our attorneys in or out of court, they know we mean business and that we have our client's interests at heart. 

      When you contact us for a free case evaluation, our attorney will investigate your injury to determine the party liable. This process involves reviewing your insurance policies and their terms.

      Next, our lawyers will gather all the necessary evidence to create a strong case against the defendant. This may include but is not limited to accident reports, witness statements, and pictures of the accidents. 

      After assembling enough evidence to prove that a particular party should compensate you for your damages, we will evaluate the extent of your injuries and losses. Our attorneys will also review every aspect of the damage, including its short-term and long-term effects.

      For example, in the unfortunate event that you become paralyzed after an accident while driving a rental car, we will evaluate the short-term effects of your condition and its impact on your life in the future. We'll then use this information to file a claim covering your current life and the future challenges arising from your new condition. 

      Once we have the right settlement amount in mind, we'll approach the defendant to inform them about their legal responsibility to compensate you for your losses. They can either settle the claim out of court, but we will file a lawsuit against them in court if they don't provide a reasonable settlement. 

      Most insurance companies would rather settle the claim out of court than face Morgan & Morgan car accident attorneys in court. This is because we have a solid record of winning up to 20 times more than the initial offer!

    • Where Is Morgan & Morgan's New York Office Located?

      In New York, you'll find us at 350 5th Ave Suite 6705, right in the Empire State Building.

    • What's Morgan & Morgan's Morgan's New York Office Phone Number?

      You can call Morgan & Morgan New York Office anytime at 212-738-6299 or send us a message online for a free case evaluation.

    • How Much Do Morgan & Morgan Car Accident Attorneys Charge?

      Our attorney fees are based on a contingency basis, meaning you don't owe us anything unless we win the case. This also means that you have nothing to lose but so much to gain when you contact Morgan & Morgan for a free, no-obligation case evaluation.

    Scroll down for more

    How It Works

    Unsure what to do next? With 35 years of experience, our personal
    injury lawyers will guide you every step of the way.

    Step 1
    1

    Contact Us 24/7 - It’s Free

    Start with a free, no-obligation case evaluation online, by phone, or via text. Tell us your story—we’re here to listen.

    Start your claim

    Step 2
    2

    Meet your dedicated attorney

    Once your case qualifies, we’ll pair you with a lawyer and a supportive team. They’ll handle everything, keep you informed, and answer all your questions.

    Meet the attorneys

    Step 3
    3

    We fight for more

    Your legal team will build a strong case, negotiate with insurance companies, and pursue the maximum results you deserve.

    Learn more about the case process

    Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. The attorneys shown in these photos may not be licensed in your state. To find an attorney licensed in your area, please visit our attorney page.

    Local Care

    Backed by America’s Largest Injury Law Firm.

    • $30 Billion
      Recovered for clients
      nationwide
    • 700,000+
      Clients and families
      served
    • 1,000+
      Attorneys across
      the country
    • 1
      Click may change your life

    We know your pain.

    John Morgan’s brother Tim was injured as a teen. Their experience with a lawyer was a nightmare. John spent 35 years building a firm to do better for families like his. And yours.

    Video thumbnail for ugbs000ml3
    Play video

    The attorney featured above is licensed in Florida. For a full list of attorneys in your state please visit our attorney page.
    Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.